final four: shana vs belldandy

Well, it was a blowout. Poor Nanoha as Chidori wipes the floor with her 61% to 39% and earning Chidori a spot in the finals. Chidori overcame two niche favorites, Suigintou and Nanoha, to reach the finals… will her general appeal (and swimsuit fanservice) be enough to make her the first AoMM March Madness champion?

image

The last semifinal match pits the two cutest chibi characters in anime history… I mean… look at them! 可愛い!!!!!!!!!!!!

image

#4 seed Shana… also Shana-tan, “Urachai! Urachai! Urachai!”

image

#7 seed Belldandy… also Mini-Bell, “It’s convenient to be small!”

226 Responses to “final four: shana vs belldandy”

  1. I can’t believe shana is winning the poll right now. I mean..loli beats goddess? Belldandy is pretty much THE perfect woman. She has awesome powers, kind, caring, faithful.

  2. This’ll be close… but I’m still voting Belldandy, if only because she can appear loli as well as chibi in the series without needing to step completely out of character, as Shakugan no Shana-tan does. :D Plus, she can destroy a lot more than Shana could, if absolutely necessary… although Shana is more emotionally capable of it than Belldandy ever would be.

  3. i forcfuly had to choose shana for the sake my love for loli is to big not even belldanady the girl i love could stop it

  4. As much as I like Shana, I have to give it to Belldandy.

    Besides, all Shana would have to do is look at Keiichi the wrong way and Belldandy would show her what for.

  5. My vote goes to Shana, but my feelings for Belldandy are with her, she was the first female anime character that I fall in love with, Arigatou Locomotion LA for that chance. And now I hope a victory for Shana, maybe tomorrow’s final episode of Shakugan no Shana can make a BIG difference between win and defeat for her.

    Go Shana! Don’t give up

  6. It seems like all you people who voted for shana are just feeling sorry for her because she’s up against Belldandy..but you all know deep down that you like belldandy better…what’s wrong with you people?

  7. So far, it looks like the roripedos are out in force… again. :D They’re voting for a child over a goddess who can LOOK like a child if she wants to.. and has been one in the manga at various times, on top of the chibi form.

  8. yea but shana has a spark that bell dont

  9. I love loli much, much more than the next guy, but come ON.
    It’s BELL. DANDY.

  10. Am I finding the irony that someone calling themselves “Celastin” isn’t voting for Belldandy?

  11. Hmm, new girl vs. old girl…

    I think I’ll go the nostalgic way. Because I wanted a perfect female vs. perfect female final match. Not loli vs. perfect female match.

  12. it’s bell-frickin’-dandy. nuff said.

    ;(

  13. Jason: Nope, although with the way Celastin in the movie acted, I’m pretty sure he was a loli too… so I guess that’s why he voted for the real child in body, rather than the ageless goddess for whom a body is a vessel easily adjusted to circumstances.

    Still, Bell HAS to carry this one through, or else Chidori will crush the competition again. At least Bell can give her a challenge.

  14. I tied it back up again, Goddess FTW.

  15. Shana ftw.

    We should have a strictly loli match and a strictly normal girls/woman match instead of what we have now.

    The lolis are getting slained and the supporters of lolis are being labelled as pedos. >.>

  16. I voted Belldandy, but either way is fine. I just hope that damn Chidori won’t won finale.

  17. I like my girls with a bit of nasty. While Belldandy is undoubtedly a true Goddess, she’s way too nice. Uruchai x3 FTW! Final week when Wednesday is also known as Shanaday. (Thurs is Naoday and Friday is Rinday.)

  18. I may sound biased but Shana FTW!!!

  19. Whoa, a 50% vs 50% result, pretty rare xD
    Bell FTW!

  20. @zyl: Wednesday is also known as Shanaday. Thurs is Naoday and Friday is Rinday

    rofl. how true, how true!

  21. Belldandy can be nasty – just look at the manga where she caused lightbulbs and the like to explode when she got jealous. :D

    Shsna’s more annoying or petty than NASTY. Give her a few years, and she’ll get that nasty quotent right up, assuming she gets to interact with people more.

  22. Belldandy all the way! I like Shana but still she’s too annoying. This poll should be done when AMG TV2 comes out next month. Shana is currently airing now while there’s nothing to advertise Belldandy. That’s too unfair! Shame on you Shana!

  23. >> 17

    Friday is Keroroday de arimasu.

    >> 22

    DVD 4 comes out this week, but who follows DVDs now? Timing is everything. Gonzaga didn’t go, “Wait, sorry, can you postpone our game because Adam Morrison has the flu? It won’t be fair if he’s running a fever of 101.” Suck it up, strap it on, and go to battle with what you have.

  24. This match is hot! 149-146 Go Shana

    Today is a decisive day for Shana, last episode of her series (in an hour airing in Japan). Belldandy made her job in the past fifteen years, let give a chance to the fresh blood.

  25. Hmm… looks like Belldandy is getting a lead now. Oh well, if she wins, it’ll make my final vote all the much easier. :D

  26. 152 vs 152?…

    *starts smashing his head against the desk*

    come on people, shana has SWORD!!!! and cuteness… so, SHE MUST WIN!!!…

    or my vote for chidori may have been in vain ;_;

  27. Ohh jojojo

    A real fight oh yeah!

    At this time, last episode of Shakugan no Shana has over in Japan, a little help for Shana would be a good idea.

    152 -152… good

  28. alright first of all, WHERE did you get that FMP image!??! I don’t think i have that one… it is my goal to get almost every FMP image that exists :P

    anyway, yeah, i voted for belldandy,… check out AMG season 1 episode 17, or maybe 18, anyway the episode where belldandy goes “crazy”… i loved that episode, not even adorable shana (with melon bread and all) can save it (don’t get me wrong i do luv shana tho…)

  29. After my crappy foreseeing on the Shana-Saber match, I simply shut up. (pssst….belldandy ftw!! ^_^)

  30. Finaly, Shakugan no Shana 24 its over…
    O_O Why? Tell me why? I want more Shana ^_^

    BUt… in the end… Shana… ups, see for yourselfs

  31. Lol, at least it leaves many possibilitieS open :)
    Shana FTW

  32. Its going Shana’s way! Muahahaha, who is this Belldandy anyways but a smelly old fat woman!

    Muahahaha.

  33. Men! This rally are killing me…

    I want to see Shakugan no Shana 24, but I have to wait until Friday… dammit!

    Until then, Shana FTW

  34. there’s a Shana movie announced today. xD I can’t wait

    Shana FTW!

  35. Yey! Shana!!! ^.^
    (I can’t belive i voted for belldandy thinking it was shana… >.

  36. Belldandy is THE anime goddess. Shana has her credits, but there’s no way loli can go against goddess. Right?

  37. Why is it that all the matches on the left side of the bracket have been relatively washouts (more than 10% victory margins) while all the matches on the right side are incredibly close?

  38. Geh, where are all the Belldandy supporters? Why is it always 51-49?? What the hell is good about Shana? She’s just some noisy brat. I’d rather see Chidori slug it out with a heavenly being than some flat brat.

  39. ガ~~~!

    Belldandy is SO BORING. She’s just too perfect. Thus I’ve never been interested in her.

    I’m not into loli or anything, but Shana is just cuter. More interesting. I actually never thought Belldandy was that pretty. She looks good depending on the picture or so. Her character design scares me… and while Shana doesn’t have the most interesting design, it has never bothered me.

    So, a vote to Shana~!

    ~亜沙のファンより~

  40. 192-191

    I personally think the character selection is kinda iffy….Nanoha over fate? Saber over Rin….. well at least belldanady do play a bigger role…but I’d rather have skuld :p

  41. 195-195 ^_^ Cool
    Ok, I can’t wait for episod 24, so I’m gtting the RAW…
    WOW! A movie, how $%&/$ great! I can’t wait to see it.

    Two more days, mmm maybe we can pass 1000 votes.

  42. Whoa! Dead tie! This’ll make for an interesting outcome. :3

  43. Deshou! Deshou! (Arinko-chan)

    Shana is going to win for sure… all my hopes are with her.

  44. More cheating. Rolled back votes 10 minutes… (don’t cheat while I’m working on the site… a bit too obvious!)

  45. … figures.

    More cheating for Shana, or did someone go devilish for Belldandy? Betting on the former, myself – since they did it to help push Shana over Saber last time.

    Here’s hoping Belldandy wins – Chidori needs worthy competition.

  46. Bell. She’s a Goddess, for goodness sake!

  47. BELLDANDY FTW!

  48. True true, A Shana in bikini can never beat Chidori in a dress. We need someone that doesn’t say “Urusai” every 5 minutes to go against Chidori’s Paper Fan of Intolerance.

  49. Makenaii Shana, gambatte!
    Wonderful final for Shakugan no Shana, and now…
    I want to look into the future with more hopes…

  50. BELLDANDY FOR THE WIN!!!

  51. Screw Belldandy!!!! Shana FTW (Really Has No choice because You screwed JUNK!!!!!

  52. Still, with all the cheating for Shana that went on… well, I honestly wish Jason had disqualified her on that basis alone, ages ago, since it repeated itself here, and if she made it to the finals, would probably repeat itself there too.

    More’s the pity – she could’ve probably stood up to Saber without the cheating.

  53. Well, i disagree, it wasn’t Shana that cheated, it was some sad idiot. I could argue that said person was doing it with the idea of being noticed and getting shana disqualified thus having Saber win, therefore I could argue that Saber should have been disqualified by defualt…

    Besto to stop the childish cheating tho, i agree there!

    People, VOTE FOR SHANA!!!
    lol
    ciao :)

  54. voted for Belldandy though I would have preferred Urd. She would have wiped out the competition. Loli-Urd FTW!!

  55. Could you marry Shana?
    Could you walk over street with Shana hand-in-hand without raising suspicion and questioned looks?

    No.

    Belldandy is the perfect wife. End.

  56. Comon people, how can you let Shana down?!?

    She promised to treat everybody who votes for her to a melonpan pool party, if she wins…

  57. wow, i just voted for shana, and i made it a dead heat, 450 to 450! awesome.

  58. whoops, i mean 225 to 225

  59. Melonpan party?? Who needs that? Belldandy can introduce us her friends to be our very own Goddess girlfriends!

  60. you forgot the POOL part of the party… :/

    Even though goddesses may be intreaguing, whats better than a cute Flame Haze O_o?

  61. I voted Shana.
    What could possibly be at the end of this road I have taken?
    *Bites into melonpan thoughtfully*

  62. Hot dang, it’s 50-50 right now! Didn’t really expect this :P.

  63. In fanct, is mor fun to be 50-50, you never know who is going to win at the very end… will see.

    Gambatte! Shana… a brilliant future is waiting for you.

  64. >> What could possibly be at the end of this road I have taken?

    17 years in jail is the average punishment for statutory rape. Heard on CNN last night when they were arguing about the Florida teacher thingie.

    (Secretly hoping for 100 comments…)

  65. I’ve been watching the polls for quite a while now… It’s still lock in a dead heat… OMG… Hopes Shana nails it…

    SHANA FTW!!!!

  66. Do pedo-rapists get a different sentence or that applies to all rapists? I’m not American so I won’t know.

  67. Jason, we want to vote her, not shag her… (well, that counts for me, at least… O_o)

    ciao :)

  68. Ok, ok, we need all kind of POV, good or bad.

    ^_^ We’re going to need a photo finish with these two
    Hey Jason, at waht time this poll ends?

  69. Shana bugs me…

    Belldandy doesn’t.

    And if (BIG if) Belldandy did, she can turn herself very very small.

    Shana….would continue to bug me…as well as possibly whip out her sword.

    vote goes to belldandy

  70. Depends on if the subject is male or female, Musashken: one such rapist got off with only 9 years for raping his stepdaughter after she fell down the stairs and lay dying on the floor, instead of calling 911 like a normal person, and another got just 60 days from the judge in Vermont for raping a seven year old for four years. Incidentally, you get more time for drunk driving causing death or even without doing so than this.

    Besides, Belldandy can be a little Flame Haze if she chooses to change form that way. Shana’s stuck as a little girl for the rest of her life, due to her job.. which will make Yuuji’s own life somewhat interesting (read: inconvenient) in the years ahead… if only because none of them will age, IIRC, which means that they’ll be eternally children despite being old enough to vote, drink, or drive.

  71. yea…i was wondering that too…when would this end? o_O

  72. BELLDANDY FOREVER AND ALWAYS, BURN ALL MAIDS (except when Belldandy is a maid) BURN THEM ALL!!!

  73. huh? what does maids have to do with this? o_O

    (trying to get the comment count to 100) xD

  74. I can only guess it had something to do with Wilhemina.

    (Doing my part to get to 100 :) )

  75. I have to say that the outcome of this vote is so close in my mind, that I actually felt compelled to vote twice (once from home and once from work), once for Belldandy and once for Shana.

    (three quarters of the way there)

  76. As probably one of the few female readers of this site, I say that Belldandy is probably one of my least favourite manga/anime heroines ever because she sets back women’s lib by at least 50 years.

    Go Shana!

  77. Let see. Make yourself this question

    How much does Shana changes her way in the series?

    And then…

    How much does Belldandy changes her way in 5 OVAS, 24 episodes and one movie?

    Sure, Belldandy has a lot of attributes that Shana doesn’t, but because her status as a goddess gave her all that, include her personality. I don’t remember any change in her way to be, apart of falling in love with Keiichi, while Shana discovers a new world that never were showed to her.

    I want some opinions please!

  78. …Shana at first sight…shes cute and adorable…
    …when getting to know her…yes shes annoying at first… (i didnt find her annoying) however when judging her character one must also consider her character development throughout the series and acknowledge how much she changed from being “annoying”…

  79. I agree with Kaei as a fellow female! eee. And Belldandy is quite annoying to me. Perfect women to all guys… haha… well except for the lolipedo’s~ In their case, I guess Shana would be perfect…

  80. No!!! There’s a tie between them! I never watched any AMG(I’ll shout OMG!if i found out that Shana loses in this match) series so i don’t know anything about Belldandy,except that she’s a Goddess,she’s perfect among men,and she loves Keiichi…..

    BUT,
    FORGET that she’s a Goddess!(i prefer Flame Hazes)
    FORGET that she’s perfect!(i hate perfect girls that caught the every male’s attention)
    FORGET that Shana’s a LOLI(at least she’s in High school.C’mon! Shana is not merely a 10 years old kind of girl,she just looked like a child)

    She beat out my big chi~chi Mai,I don’t think she’s that super pretty (especially in her latest looks),I like Rie Kugimiya,and MOST of all:I LOVE LOLIS(it will be my pleasure if i have Shana as my girlfriend^-^)!!

    So i’m voting for Shana!! For the sake of Nanoha’s loss to Chidori,hope that Shana will win for LOLIs!! GO LOLI!!! GO SHANA-CHAN!!!

  81. Well, you don’t need to pe a lolipedo to like Shana better than the competition presented here… The competittion is simply… too much. As others have said, not much character developepent and too perfect…

    Personally, I’d love to have been able to remain a kid all of my life lol :P

  82. Polls run for three days, so tomorrow night. But if it’s still very close, I’ll declare overtime and run it a bit longer. Details tomorrow… if I’m not drunk after work.

  83. Shana doesn’t develop all that much, ultimately, IMO: she basically stays the same, but it’s more that she develops feelings for Yuuji, and the human world in general, which in the end leads to her final actions in the end of the series. Yuuji is somewhat better than Keiichi, IMO, if only because he’s somewhat more useful in terms of the show… although both of them are heads and tails above many other male lead characters in anime.

    Personally, I don’t see how Shana going around in bandages or refusing to admit she has feelings for Yuuji advances the cause of women’s lib any, but that’s just me. Sure, she has a sword and kills things… but Wilhemina and Margery together perpetrate the stereotypes that women must either be sexy and brazen or demure and subservient… except when it comes to killing people.

  84. shan all the way belldandy seems cool but too perfect need more human flaws here

  85. Well, my original point was to make sure you people remember this.. SHANA is not only a LOLI icon, she has more cualitis within. And the fact this match is sod tie is because many of us knows that truth.

    Everybody have their opinions, so… let it be.

  86. Technically she’s not loli you know… Time flows differently for the chibi flamehaze…

  87. Belldandy does have her flaws. And it’s these moments which makes AMG so fun to read. Whenever some girl gets cozy with Keiichi, Bell’s “perfect” composure doesn’t seem to change but we can see in her eyes the spark of jealousy and poof something explodes in the house for no reason. Never make a goddess jealous. Because AMG is such a long series, it takes quite a long time for Bell to gain human traits but eventually she does.

  88. *high-fives Tess* Agree with you on all points =)

    To Haesslich: You missed my point. Firstly – where did I say Shana advances women’s lib? I just said that Belldandy sets it back.

    Secondly I haven’t finished Shakugan yet (waaaaaay too much stuff to catch up on this past couple of seasons >_

  89. (squee! I had comment 88. I feel lucky. And doing my job to advance it past the 90 mark, but at this rate, I’m sure it’ll be past 100 by the time I wake up next morning.)

  90. Shana for me. I like Belldandy too, but my preference for the Flame Haze takes precedence over almost every other anime girl. =P

  91. I have no clue who this Shana person even is.. but i’m about a year behind on anime since i dont have much time ever since i graduated :(

    How can anyone even think about voting against Bell-sama, she’s like the perfect girlfriend. C’mon people.. use your hearts, not your toes!!!!

  92. “jason Says: … if it’s still very close, I’ll declare overtime and run it a bit longer.”

    You mean if Belldandy losses you’ll go into overtime right?! Good work on the choice of screen caps too. =)

    92nd!

  93. But… don’t come after a wial party ^_^
    I feel that OT… wow almost 600 votes

    Gambatte! Shana-chan… 7 more to go.

  94. AND THE WAR RAGES ON, BELLDANDY TAKES THE LEAD THANKS TO GENERAL KAMZU’S EFFORTS.

  95. ^_^ well, boku-tachi

    Call to th reinforsments, we need to bring Shana again to th lead. Everybody who can vote, do it.

    Im’ so exited… I never felt this way in a very long time

  96. lol… me too
    Too bad i’m not in school now or else i could have get everyone to vote… Now asking all my friends on msn to help…

  97. Lol, isn’t that a bit of a cheat… ;)

  98. no… as long as one vote per person, it OK
    ^_^ At least that doesn’t sound like cheating at all.
    24 hours more to go, or maybe a little bit more…

    98… 2 more

  99. well, i suppose, but If someone dosn’t really know what hes voting about, and is only voting because of hsi freind telling him, its a bit empty of a bote, don’t you think ;)

    but yes, TECHNICALLY it isn’t cheating :D

    Comone SHANA fans… we can’t loose to a mere Godess!!! :)

    ciao :)

  100. YATA!! 100 replays Jason

    Jejeje who wrote this math program…
    51-50 % over 600 votes, come on, a elementary school kik could do a better job than that…

    Shana, you can do it

  101. haha… totally agree wif emuLOAD.
    Anyway, all my friends are watching animes partly because of my influence. Then i’m trying to get them to vote, on their free will of course. Depends on who they vote for… Playing dirty is what i hate most. :p

    SHANA FTW!!!

  102. Come on Bell! You can do it! Bell’s jealousy can definitely beat Shana’s jealousy. Belldandy Jealousy Power=exploding houses, summoning rain storms and a Keiichi that learns his lesson. Shana Jealousy Power= Usurai!^100 (Shut up already) and a Clueless Yuji(moron). Sheesh I feel sorry for Kazumi.

  103. “Jejeje who wrote this math program…
    51-50 % over 600 votes, come on, a elementary school kik could do a better job than that…”

    huh… what? O_o
    Why can’t there be 51-50 over 600 votes ???

    ciao :)

  104. kaei: And Chigusa the perfect housewife doesn’t set women’s lib back just as bad? Shana spending a whole episode trying to learn to cook for Yuuji, Kazumi being indecisive, Marjorie/Margery showing off her… assets… every chance she gets and playing the role of the wanton woman, and Wilhemina in her meido aren’t equally detrimental to a goddess who’s about as domestic as Chigusa?

    Most of the supporting female cast in SnS are in very traditional female roles (victims, sexpots, housewives, maids). In contrast, AMG has Megumi (female biker/mechanic type), Sora (member of the Auto Club, later its president), Chihiro Fujimi (founder and former president of the Auto Club, former member of a racing team pit crew, current owner of a customizing/chop shop for bikes, enterpreneur), and even Urd and Skuld used to run Yggdrasil as debuggers and system admins – all very non-traditional, technical trades and occupations which contrast strongly with the very ‘feminine’ roles that Chigusa and the others in SnS occupy. And none of AMG’s female supporting cast spend much time as victims of circumstance, unlike Hirai Yukari who ends up being completely helpless and ‘disappeared’, never to be spoken of again?

    And… somehow… a goddess whose sisters were sysadmins for a goddess-supporting computer system, who works in the chop-shop run by another woman enterpreneur, whose boyfriend’s sister is tomboy, and who is also a member of an auto club which has a visible female presence there besides herself, founded by the woman whose shop she works at now… completely sets Women’s Lib back more than a show where women are either victims, sexpots, or housewives and maids?

  105. Detrimental to ‘the cause’ as much as, even. Bah.

  106. Way to go Haesslich! Can I vote for you instead? lol

  107. I hadn’t noticed we were voting for the most feminist show O_o I thought it was abut the girls… go figure…

    oh well, ciao :)

  108. Don’t get me wrong people. I actually enjoy watching Shana anime but it’s the story that gets me going. I seriously don’t give a damn about how Yuji finally ends up with Shana (haven’t watched ep 24 btw) since he’s such an idiot. Even Shirou of FSN is beginning to be a lesser moron than Yuji. And if Kazumi is on the poll, I’d rather vote for her than Shana. At least Kazumi works hard to get Yuji look at her. I don’t hate Shana (I find Shana-tan cute) but I think there are better anime brats out there that deserve better votes.

  109. “well, i suppose, but If someone dosn’t really know what hes voting about, and is only voting because of hsi freind telling him, its a bit empty of a bote, don’t you think ;)

    but yes, TECHNICALLY it isn’t cheating :D”

    I don’t see how this kind of “legal” cheating is any different from the regular cheating. You are using your control over your friends to gain more influence in the voting. Regular cheaters are using their control over computers to gain more influence in the voting.

    Anyway, I am sure that cheating of both kinds happen regularly for both contestants here.

  110. We have to learn and live with it.
    Belldandy is taking the laed… 16 votes ahead.

  111. BTW > Just to make things clear, I do NOT agree with influencing aquaintances to vote, nor do I do it (just want to avoid misunderstandings).

    COMON SHANA PEOPLE!!!

  112. Oops. I guess I shouldn’t have used “you” after quoting you on this discussion.

    Sorry about that.

  113. Wow… thanks guys, you made my day. You guys are awesome. Never thought I could get a 100+ comment post on this blog.

    People shouldn’t bribe or blackmail others to vote, but publicity and advertising is allowed. I’ve already seen a handful of other blogs and a few forum posts urging people to vote one way or another.

    Technically, the poll ends when I get home tomorrow. Though if the vote is close (50-50 still) I may roll it to Saturday.

  114. A promise is a promise… 100 comments? Check!

    I know, its a little unfair doing that, but if that people can make their pick by themselfs, its allright

    Maybe we’re going to need Saturday ^_^

    Gambatte! Shana-chan… Daisuki

  115. BELLDANDY, MY GODDESS. For lolis, there’s still mini-Belldandy also.

  116. Well, this is one heck of a poll fight. It’s really fun. Come on Belldandy! You may be a goddess but you need to give your all against Shana! Go Go Goddess! (Pun not included)

  117. If posting an opinion here = vote, I vote for Shana (and before the anti-loli jump on me and accuse me of pedophillia, I’m a girl you perverts)

    I hated the very image that Belldandy projected. “Perfect girl”, falls for a colorless, characterless idiot. Hell, Belldandy herself was a portrait of boring pastels anyway, and her sugary sweetness made my teeth grind. “Perfect wife?” I guess the men who call her that want a sweet little house slave, not a real woman with any sort of passion and fire.

    As someone said, she set women’s lib back 50 years, but I’ll say instead she set it back a full 100.

    FLAME HAZE FTW. I go for personality over saccharine sugar substitutes!

  118. how did bell pull ahead by 22 votes? O_O this is odd… >__> Somehow i dont think there are 642 ppl that are voting… >_

  119. Did you not read the last 30 posts? It seems that someone is stuffing ballots (or just “working very hard”) for bell some way or another.

  120. Oh no… Well, we probaly got more Bell fans than Shana fans out there. Since AMG has much more vol. of series than Shana… T_T
    I’m rooting for Shana all the way!

    SHANA FTW!!!

  121. How come Shana is losing???I know there are a lot of Shana fans out there…We need to act now…Vote for Shana!!!Influence ur friends to vote for Shana as well…This is the most crucial time in our lives as Shana fans…Shana needs us!!!Don’t let her down!!!

  122. but the most votes in any of AoMM’s polls was like 460….this one is almost 200 more. O_O

    Not to mention that Shana was winning for a while with ~10 votes above bell at 460 votes total, most of the night, then i come on later at night and bell pulls ahead by 22. o_O

  123. Lol, with the results this vote is yelding, you should modify your post listing the best ways for increasing blog traffic… “#1 Have a vote which splits the Animè world in half, preferebly involving lovely lolis and perfect goddesses”

    Shana, after a burning decrease in votes is finally catching up again!
    Comon people!!! Don’t let shana down, she may be forced to test nietono no shana’s sharpness on you if she looses…. [no, thats not a threat aimed at increasing shana’s votes…. seriously… AGENT… I’m INNOCENT… SHES 18… wha… wher’s that going…]

    ciao :)

  124. Do you guys think that this poll would reach at least to have 1000 votes?

    Come on those who have not voted… Vote for Shana since she’s the most kawaii Flame Haze around.

    SHANA FTW!!!

  125. Kinda proves this blog’s popularity, don’t it? =D

  126. Seriously, AMG has a much longer lifespan than Shana(come on, AMG is already 10+ years while Shana is only out like this year and who the hell reads the Shana novels other than the Japanese?). So it’s inevitable that there should be a larger fanbase for Bell than Shana. You Shana fans should be proud that you’re neck to neck with Bell.

    As for you female Bell-haters, don’t even talk abt Women’s lib here. This is a poll of female characters (which is about as degrading as a Miss Universe contest) for hormonal fanboys like me. And this is ANIME, purely fictitious so there’s nothing wrong to fantasize abt some “perfect” woman.

    Most importantly, anime is a Japanese product. Many of you seem to forget the very core of Japanese social values, the partriachal influence is still very much present in today’s Japan. The Yamato Nadeshiko (The Perfect Japanese Female Homemaker) concept was a highly regarded ideal in Japan. Even now, Japanese women aim to be the perfect housewife. There’s nothing much the rest of the world can do about this. Belldandy is just a remnant avatar of what a Nadeshiko is.

  127. Well, what you just said cold be twisted to say…

    Heck, if Shana managed to take over the fanbase THIS MUCH in little less than a year, she must REALLY be something ;)

    ciao :)

  128. That’s because many Shana viewers are probably newbie anime viewers. Belldandy supporters are probably old-timer anime viewers like me. We have seen so many animes in one lifetime and seriously, Shana is just one of them. However series like AMG are actually considered classics and they leave deep impressions in the otaku world (you can’t deny that AMG was freaking popular during its time in Japan). In 10 years time, if Shana is still popular and around, we will be having the exact same argument with fans of a popular anime 10 years later. The reason why so many pple voted for Shana is because it’s one of the most popular series THIS year. I doubt most of the Belldandy supporters actually know about this site. Even I knew abt this only when I heard abt the Shana vs Saber poll from another forum. And that’s because I’m a FSN fan.

  129. And I give Jason 3 thumbs up for giving me something so interesting to read.

  130. Well, you do have a point there, and while I admit that 10 years ago I was faar to young to be exposed to the full spectra of animè, I am not fully a newcommer though (as I have watched several anime, including the two discussed here), and have also managed to go throughs everal of the classics. Having seen shana, including the ending, I think it was a rather deserving series not only as 05-06 goes, but also as older series go. Not the best series in hsitory nor my favourite, it provided a nice diversion from the many series which have been going on one after the other, after all it’s the way the world should go, the youngsters taking the place of the geezers :D

    TBH what REALLY won shana over me was her Urmi-like act during the beginnign when she appeard in school, as Urumi is probabelly one of my ABOSULTE animè favourite characters, anihilating even beloved Shana here…

    But hey, de gustibus non est disputandum, so let’s just all praise the blog for the fun (it really kept me going through the _two_ assigments which have kept me busy for the last, uhm, 30 hours straight :P)

    ciao :)

  131. After reading all these posts i think i am clearly Belldandy’s side now. Shana is popular at the moment, but i doubt anyone remember her 2015. It’s hard to find character that first aired 12 years ago and still has so large fanbase among anime “veterans”.

  132. Interesting… the 666th vote was for Belldandy then… that makes it a great slogan then…

    A VOTE FOR Belldandy IS A VOTE FOR THE DEVIL!
    VOTE SHANA!!!

  133. I’m not arguing about whether Shakugan as an entire show advances women’s lib at all! And AGAIN, I haven’t seen the entire series, so I don’t even know some of the characters mentioned yet – and this isn’t a vote between Ah Megamisama and Shakugan no Shana as series, it’s a vote between BELLDANDY and SHANA as characters – as a CHARACTER as tons of people have mentioned before, Belldandy possesses all those “nadeshiko” / perfect woman traits that ANY real woman today should not be subject to and expect to be upheld. That applies to Belldandy REGARDLESS of her opponent.

    I am not making a “Shana > Belldandy” comparison here, nor am I trying to swing votes in these comments (cos hey, we all know how effective a post would be here in changing your minds, right?)

    And look at the legion of fans that love her because of those perfect qualities – over decades. OVER DECADES! Look at that idealism there! I mean, there’s nothing with liking a perfect character – go for it, it’s your fandom. I will never tell another person to “like this character” or “hate this character” because I don’t believe in changing people’s minds like that. I just figured I’d state my opinion here along with everyone else. If you don’t like it that’s your freedom, but I don’t like my comments being misconstrued. Because this discussion can easily lead to wild women-vs-men arguments I’m just going to stop here because it wasn’t my intent to start such a discussion.

    Dang this was long, but, to the poster that said this is a poll for fanboys only – what, girls can read Jason’s posts and enjoy his comments, but take part in anything interactive he puts up on his site? We like anime damnit! Regardless of who its target audience (lolifans/male/teenageboys/cough) is. You can’t drive us away! *shakes fist*

    Smiley for the humour impaired =)

  134. Ugh, I meant, “can’t take part in anything interactive etc”

    And to add – interesting comment about the age of a series. If Asuka/Rei (Evangelion) or Lina Inverse (Slayers) or other 90s popular series were in this poll, wonder how it would swing?

  135. Belldandy=Mary Sue
    Mary Sue=Trash
    Belldandy Trash…
    Belldandy is Overrated…
    “Being Perfect is most the boring thing”
    Just Like Kira Geezus Cries Yamato!!!!!!

  136. Call them “veterans” all day but seriously they’re just Fanboys drooling over the most perfect piece of shit. It’s not how many years you’ve logged watching the anime. It’s how you take information or ideals from it.What does the word “veteran” mean anyway, AMG has been for how long, It’s just like comparing DBZ and Naruto in the US. It’s nonsense. Logic would tell you that intially, the anime with longer time stayed would go over, but story-wise, DBZ is crap compared to Naruto or Bleach. So what If people like Gundam Wing Better than Zeta or CCA . Does that mean that the people who liked Gundam Wing are “veterans” using the fact that Gundam Wing has been aired for more times than Z-Gundam. Proclaiming Yourselves as Veterans…lol, people who claim to be at the top, usually fall straight to the bottom.

  137. Wait… I don’t understand the comparison…
    Belldandy is a Goddess, replete with a Goddess’ knowledge and maturity. She’s in her 20s and has gorgeous hair and physique. Belldandy is kind and generous and funloving.

    Shana… Shana is so useless she didn’t even have a name at the beginning of the show. She’s a stupid warrior who can’t think for herself and has above average knowledge. She is like… 4 a half feet tall and has a big sword ^^;;; Among the various pedo-fanservice shots of her, she’s got to have one of the most child-like bodies in all of anime. Yet, she somehow passes as a high school student. ^^ Probably her only redeeming quality is her hair and eye color, which she wasn’t born with. Lame. Shana is greedy, stupid, antisocial and for the most part, uninteresting.

    I. Don’t. Understand. The. Comparison. ^^

  138. “Shana is popular at the moment, but i doubt anyone remember her 2015”

    Well… Back at Kousuke Fujishima’s home
    “Well the fools have taken my bait, I’ll get more money enough for me to live 3 lifespans over”

  139. lol, What’s interesting with somebody as STAGNANT AS BELLDADY? At least we see progression with Shana. While Belldandy has always remained herself from friggin day one…
    SHE’S a MARY SUE… A bunch of Hypocrites Bashing on Lacus Clyne While putting Bellperfect’s ASS UP!

  140. And Shana’s author who I don’t even care enough to look up is probably thinking.

    “Wow! I never thought there were so many SICKOS in the world today.”

  141. Well, I suppose that voicing my reasons for voting against Belldany won’t change a thing, since anyone reading this has probably voted already. But as a guy, I have to say that this “perfect” woman thing just doesn’t work for me.

    Then again, I find it hard to believe that any woman would want to aspire just to become a perfect housewife. I guess people each have their ambitions and that’s just one that I won’t ever understand.

  142. Sheesh, stop cussing Belldandy and say something good about Shana for god’s sake. I keep hearing about “She’s so perfect and so boring bla bla”. Say something else. And no, I didn’t say I didn’t like women in this poll. I just like to be direct. Polls like this need people like us to sprout crap at each other. That way it’ll be fun.

    So come on, do you seriously think Chidori will lose to Shana? If we go by Dr. Jack’s way, Chidori will beat Shana in so many catagories. Bikinis, Boyfriends, Personalities, Intolerance levels etc. Shana will beat Chidori in the Loli and Fight department but that’s pretty much it. At least Belldandy has more traits to give Chidori a run for her money.

  143. What I don’t understand is why so many people here seem to make the analogy “Likes Shana –> Is a pedofile”… TBH, while I voted for Shana, I don’t go around stalking 12 year olds or such things O_o (and I’m ready to assume that a vast majority of the people that voted for her feel the same).
    I don’t argue that some of the people voting for shana may or may not be lolifanboys, but its, in a way, rather limiting to see everything purely under sexual / full of malice point of view.

    We are not voting for “the character we’d love to shag the most” are we?

    Am I a sicko for voting for shana O_o realy don’t think so… Oh, and per la cronaca, Shana is by no means one of the most “pornographic” / “perverted” shows to be produced… Even simple competitors such as Kasimasi beat it.

    Ok, sometimes Shana runs around naked in bandages, and there are several mild and not-so-mild sexual images created throughput the show, but that is not pornographic at all, and I beleave the show was made in a manner balanced enough to avoid making the fanservice take over the quality of the story overall.

    Well, for the few of you who kept up with all the nonesense so far, my point simply sumarises to my overall “annoyance” o this idea that everybody here voting for shana are busy drooling over some pedoerotic fantasy while hitting the vote button…

    Anime, after all, are not about the sex and the fanserviece (well, in part they are, but not entirely), but are about the story as well, and I don’t see why someone shouldn’t be able to like Shana for reasons other than the random pool episode and the cospicuous panty shots offered in the last battle…

    Oh well,
    once again,
    back to assignments…

    ciao :)

  144. @Musashiken: Fully agree with the first bit of your post tho, ther’s no gain in simply taunting the rival, when campaining. As a amtter of fact that wopuld only be detremental in the long run.

    So, to do my service here, SHANA IS COOL; VOTE FOR HER :D
    Meh, tbh anyone that got here probabelly has already voted anyways ;) :P

    ciao :)

  145. WOW lots of posts but man come on this is a popularity poll. Just as the two cadidates are diffrent. WE ALL ARE DIFFRENT TOO. We each have are likes and dislikes. some of us like the perfect house wife and some like someone with their good-sides and bad-sides. Some of us are attracted to the ideal perfect person and some i guess are attracted to things that satisfiy their inner lolipedofin. Either way arguing about who is better is kinda pointless but very fun to read.

  146. Well… let’s say that if I was interested in doing something other than pointless, i wouldn’t be here in the firstplace ;)

    Not all good things are meant to be purposefilling or, as a matter of fact, of any use at all… At least we can argue over things that do not pose the risk of turning into some kind of international incident :D

    ciao :)

  147. I do not call myself a veteran just because I’ve seen all the animes you stated above. I’m merely one who watches too much anime. And I agree that DBZ wasn’t as “great” as Naruto or Bleach but that’s too unfair a comparison. DBZ was the pioneer in introducing fireball and quick fighting techniques to manga. It was revolutionary during its time. How the hell you think recent authors got their ideas and influences in fighting mangas?? And I LOVE the old Gundam series (Z, ZZ ec). But I also like Gundam wing for its refreshing use of Bishonen protagonists. The thing about AMG is that after all these years, it’s still going strong! And it’s keeping up with times. If I were to compare AMG with even older classics like Maison Ikkoku, hell I’d still be in a loss since I respect these titles.

  148. >>17 years in jail is the average punishment for statutory rape. Heard on CNN >>last night when they were arguing about the Florida teacher thingie.

    Dude… I’m 14.

  149. Hmm, do minors get affected by sentences? Like do they get jailed for raping another minor?…

    Mwahaha, you must be proud of your blog Jason. We’re actually talking about rape sentences which is so goddamn far off-topic.

  150. Not follwing the same laws, yes. At least for italy, minors who engage in sexual activity with other agreeing minors, providing the age difference is not extreeme (like 13 and 17 or something like that) its not illegal. The age of consent there for example is 14, but rape is a statute which is above any other law, including age restricitons. If a minor does rape another person, be it a minor or an overaged person, the minor can still pe prosecuted under appling minor laws. This, of course, usually differs from the normal alws and sentences which are produced for adults, but yes, rape would be prosecuted. I’m sure this is the same in pretty much any other country, special cases exempted of course.

    BTW: if you’re 14 you shouldn’t be reading this blog, it’ll damage your brain and wou’ll end up like the rest of the people here, or if all goes bad, like the blogger that hosts the place… run away till you can! :P [yes this part was a joke, don’t ban me :P]

    ciao :)

  151. belldandy!!! i’m voting belldandy!!! for several reason!
    1. her ability to travel through mirrors is awesome
    2. her fashion sense ^^
    3. woman has amazing cooking skillz!
    4. she can ride one of those cool sidecar racing bikes! XD
    5. her earrings turn into staffs of justice! ^^
    6. she has an angel inside her!
    7. her gravity-defying hair
    8. she’s so damn cute!! ^^
    9. its fun and relatively easy to cosplay as her

    and, finally…

    10. the line “aaah! i feel so mellow-mellow!” from the oav. ^^

  152. Oh yeah the “mellow mellow” line. That was top-notch. lol. Hmm I really like Shanatan’s “Uruchaii!!”(hated the original’s “Urusai”) but damn, you just reminded me of that “mellow” line. Another +1 for Belldandy.

  153. Wow. If you noticed i used quotation marks meaning it was half serious. Just take it easy, this suppose to be fun…

  154. One thing I will note – Belldandy has evolved over the years, although at heart she’s still a ‘nice person’ with darker aspects to her personality which have revealed themselves over the years.. which she’s had to deal with.

    Shana, at the start, didn’t have much of a personality at all, in contrast – but over the course of the show, she’s picked up one; she’s a classic tsundere-type, although it took the Ball Masque arc, and Wilhemina repeatedly trying to kill Yuuji, to admit to herself (and then him) that she did like him, even if she’s not quite sure of why she does so.

    Honestly, part of her (Shana’s) popularity here is that she’s got a show which is current, which makes her a hot property, anime-wise. Between the fact her series JUST ended, and the announcement that she’s got a movie upcoming, she’s very much in the minds of many new (or at least newly returned) anime voters. Belldandy’s series ended last year, and the new season hasn’t started yet… PLUS her movie was a few years back, along with the OVAs, which means that her popularity is based mostly on people who remember those, and who follow the ongoing manga series. Some of the conflicts I’ve seen on this thread stem from that ‘new girl versus established character’ arguments, although the ‘women’s lib’ ones… well, Shana learning to cook for Yuuji to make him like her, and the other main female character being very ‘stereotypical submissive stalker’ girl aren’t exactly outstanding examples of progress for women characters either. Even BELLDANDY is out in the workforce now, albeit of her own free will and to help Keiichi and Chihiro at their shop.

    Still, why bother stuffing the ballot box? This has happened for Shana at least twice now (well, three times in total: two during the first vote against Mai, once here), and was why I initially commented she should be disqualified. For those who suggested someone stuffing the ballot box was trying to get Belldandy advanced through default, I have to point back to the previous two attempts where this did NOT happen, so suspect they’re just being idiots. Advertising the vote on your blog’s fine – Kurogane did it, and in a way which isn’t more than a simple ‘Shana fans, go vote!’ statement, which works for me. Encouraging people to vote for Shana because “Belldandy’s old and domestic or too perfect” isn’t, just as telling people on your blog not to vote for Shana because she’s a useless sword-wielding maniac who appears in bandages more often than Rei isn’t.

    Incidentally, I could’ve done without all the panty flashes in the last ep – Marjorie by herself is enough fanservice for almost anybody. Remember her grabbing Eita and Ike and holding them to her at the end? Now THAT’S fanservice. :D

  155. Hey Anga, is fun don’t you see?

    Everyone is giving everything for her favorite character, and yet there is still a lot to say about it. After see more than 200 anime series, 80 anime movies and sort of 900 OVAS, (more than 1.4 TB in storage) you have a lot to argue with everyone here.

    I want to say this… GO FOR IT! Shana or Belldandy!

  156. Yup it is supposed to be fun bantering. And I’m not even half serious. But hell, Can you believe that this is the only topic that has over a hundred posts?? That’s insane man! Even the earlier polls weren’t so fanatic. Gosh I gotta start reading the other topics.

  157. Syaoran Li: mainly refered to message 136.

  158. >> This is a poll of female characters (which is about as degrading as a Miss Universe contest)

    No, an episode of Kage Kara Mamorou is as degrading as a Miss Universe contest. This is more like Miss America, with talent competition and ugly one piece swimsuits.

    >> A VOTE FOR Belldandy IS A VOTE FOR THE DEVIL!

    Wasn’t this how Nanoha beat Lacus? Demon Loli ousts Evil Despot…

    >> if all goes bad, like the blogger that hosts the place

    You must have me confused with another blogger… AoMM has always been known for its Meido Power Rankings rather than Loli Power Rankings.

    I also want to comment on two running themes…

    “Belldandy is boring because she’s perfect.” K1’s life is nowhere boring. In fact, for the past 18 years, it’s been pretty interesting.

    “Shana won’t be remembered 10 years from now.” Who knows? Maybe she and Yuji will become the next Chidori and Sagara.

  159. Jason is right, nobody knows whats going to happen in the next five-ten years, maybe Ah My Goddess would be popular, maybe Shakugan no Shana grow up like FMP! (more than 3 anim e series), or maybe non of it. Just keep watching until the very end…

  160. Now that you’re done kissing ass, lets get back to voting for Belldandy shall we? =D

  161. Jason, you KNOW I was joking there right ;) Oh and I wasn’t referring to the loli stuff anyways, the going abd was referring to spending lots of time watching anime and writing about it, but it wasn’t meant to be serious :)

    Same goes for the vote for the devil bit…

    ciao :D

  162. Crap…

    I was going to say something right now, but my mind is tired…
    Win or defeat for one of them is inevitable (stupid mind, stupid comment)
    Whatever, Belldandy or Shana, this already is a great fight, not only for the poll, but because every single person said something in behalf or disagree with others opinions.
    Like a big debate between Shana & Belldandy
    I think Belldandy is going to take the win at the last minute, but as an old otaku in this kind of stuff… hope is the only thing you have in the end.

  163. Yeah… it’s getting a wee bit tiring for me too. Think I’ll take a break from all this. Belldandy or Shana is fine… I mean GO! GO! GODDESS!!!…ack (last spurt of effort before spitting blood)

  164. LOL, may be tiring, but definitelly ahs been fun, at least untill so far.

    Heck, i think J would have obtained less of an impact if he opened a poll on Who’s better, God or Allah O_o

    Even though having been here for the last thirtysomething hours does make it a bit tiring…

    (No I wasn’t actually staring at the page clicking F5 every three minutes, i was doing work and being very distracted at it…)

    Win the best!
    (i.e. Shana…) :rolleyes:whistle:

    ciao :)

  165. Holy sh…nikes…
    They’re dead even…

    GO FOR THE WIN SHANA-KUN!

  166. Belldandy! No other way!

  167. Belldandy, without any exception!

  168. Err… Well, I voted Belldandy.

    …then again, I didn’t have much choice though, lol. I had Kamzu & Fenny looming over my shoulder with promises of pain if I didn’t vote her.

    ^^;

    Let’s not invoke their wrath…

  169. I’m so torn. Do I want Belldandy to win because I like her better, or do I want Shana to win because I’m pretty sure she’d lose to Chidori, whom I like best of all?

    This one’s going to be a nail-biter until the end.

  170. March 24, 16:11 / Center America time

    375-370 for Shana… I don’t see her on top since 295-292

  171. i wonder if shana will get this much support against chidori. =)

  172. Maybe… like a final match in World Cup or Super Bowl

    Othwerwise, after a tie fight between these two, the final match has to top-noch

    Six more hours to deathline… I think we’re going to OT

  173. Well, best wishes to whoever wins~ I think everyone should just be happy with voting for whoever they like more.

    I’ve watched all of AMG! and Shana, and Shana just happens to be who I like more. So although it’s easy to get caught up in arguing why one should vote for this character or that character (myself included), all you need to do is vote for which you like more~

    Aaaaand… because I love to put my input in so much, I must make a comment on the post from a while ago saying how AMG supporting girls show more rejection to female gender roles when compared to Shana supporting girls. That was a bad, for lack of a better word, point to make. It is a fight between Shana and Belldandy themselves, after all~

    And I do not see Shana wanting to learn to cook to be something she should be attacked on so quickly. I am quite a femminist, and I see nothing wrong with cooking. Or wanting to learn to cook for someone important. I have that feeling myself. But when a couple is living together, I believe both people should do equal work, both at home and at their respective workplaces.

    I could go on forever on this subject and in much more detail… *curses her Social Anthropology class*

    Off topic, anyone know a good ethnography I could read? I need it for a project…

  174. bell man all the way

  175. Go Shana!

    Hmm… my boyfriend has most of the cooking responsibilities in our relationship…. But yeah, I agree with the sentiment of wanting to make something nice for the person they like.

    Think we’ll hit 200 before tonight?

  176. Gomen Tess, dunno…

    In the bottom of my heart I love Belldandy, because Ah My Goddess was the first anime series (OVA in that time) that I was aware, like my first time. After more than seven years along the road… more than 500 anime series, more than 100 movies, and more than 700 OVAs, is hard to say how much am I attached to some characters. Indeed Belldandy is one of the most loved by me, but that doesn’t mean I can appreciate in different ways every character I saw. The first time I knew about Shakugan no Shana was on October 2005, thanks to a good pal and his habit of showed me everything about Anime Network. After seeing the trailer, I make big hopes for Shakugan no Shana, and thankfully my guess was right. Since then, week after week, episode after episode, Shana make a space in my mind, not because I like lolis, the only fact I know for sure is that I like her way to be… is like when you fall in love with somebody, at the beginning you don’t now why, but slowly your mind learn to deal with it.

    Maybe Shakugan no Shana is still in diapers, but every history has a beginning, then every step help it to be remembered or forgotten. A few hours remains to the death line, but these three days had been fun… so, let support our favorite until the end.

  177. Go Shana!!!!

  178. Doing my bit to contribute to the big 200, but nonetheless I’ll still vote for Bell.

  179. Belldandy.

  180. Cheating for both sides… since it’s still close, it’s going to overtime… details later tonight.

  181. I voted for Belldandy :D

    Call me a traditionalist but i’d like my own Belldandy of sorts

    can be a bit clueless and airheaded at times but her pro’s outweigh her cons :D

  182. Ohh that make sense, because I remember Shana winning by 9 votes, and now Belldandy has th lead… damm you cheaters

    ^_^ YATA! Overtime

  183. Match ends at midnight PST. I will scan the votes one last time then to make sure there’s no blatant cheating, and we’ll move onto the final match.

  184. C’mon, let’s make this a fair Fight…..

    Go Shana!!!

  185. Thank you Jason

    I just hope Shana can win against all odds…
    But ifshe loss, I’m ok with it

    A little bit more to go…

  186. Haha, what do you mean “IF” she loses? She’s gonna lose buddy, theres no question about it.

  187. I don’t know, if Jason found somthing wrong, maybe Shana can make a comeback… but maybe not

  188. 186>>> Well u never know, theres still about 3 hours and 8 minutes left till the polls close. Lets just pray that this doesnt become another florida recount. So everyone VOTE FOR YOUR FAVORITE REPUBLICAN OR DEMOCRAT…. i mean LOLI (not really loli but oh well) or GODDESS.

  189. itsss sooooo difficult….why it had to be like this? ……still bell-chidori will make a better match.

  190. WOOT 200th comment WOOOO!!!!!!
    wow 100 comments was a surprize but now we reached 200
    congrats jason

  191. LOL i jumped the gun =_=;;;;;
    well thats for the future in about half an hour or so since i know we can get that many comments by then.

    part of me hopes for Shana but then again Bell has her own charm but i havent watched much of AMG so i cant really make a clear decision and also shana wasnt really that long

  192. Shana does have some kickass moves and a sword to match ^^ but Bell won me over long before Shana was a blip on the radar :D

  193. MMM… another Florida? I hop not ^_^

    Shana make a good job so far, but maybe this match is over already…

  194. I vote… Belldandy.

    Surprised?

  195. Personally, I have to agree that bringing anime and different culture roles and rules into a discussion regarding gender politics and theory is a bad idea. However… no matter which side you’ve voted for, I’d have to say that this is a nice, tight race – as tight as the Mai/Belldandy one, with good points for both characters.

    We’ll see how Shana does in the movie… and if she and Kazumi get any further in their War over Yuuji than they did in the series since he hasn’t commited to ANYONE yet, merely promising Shana that she wouldn’t face her possible end alone, which by itself may mean either true friendship… or perhaps something a bit more. We just don’t know yet.

  196. Freaking yeah!

    Maybe the movie, like FMA, plays like an epilogue for Shakugan no Shana. Tonikaku, Shana 4ever

  197. Personally, I voted for Shana because although I liked Aa! Megami-sama! manga, it seemed I enjoyed it more for the side characters than the static personalities of Keiichi and Belldandy (the TV series was blah).

    Also, reading through the posts, seems like this poll really brought out “strong” feelings from everyone, for better or for worse, lol.

  198. …wow 800 votes…broke the reccord by almost double…
    …btw almost 200 posts eh…

  199. My vote goes for Belldandy

  200. …200th post…muhahaha…

  201. YATA!! 100 comment was mine, and now 200 ^_^

    Well, Jason is beeing a little good with Shana fans…
    Shana could lost today, but she has a brilliant future

    Good luck Belldandy…

  202. And it’s over… Belldandy over Shana 51-49 (408-394). Last match coming up soon…

  203. That was one HELL of a vte shootout, not bad, not bad at all… shama Shana lost, well done Goddess!

    ciao :)

  204. LOL! Was there ever a doubt? Belldandy won, thanks to all who won the day for team AMS, the rest of you blasphemers will get whats coming to ya. =D

  205. lovely to see how genuine and honest the Belldandy fans are ;) Very sportly too :P

    Meh, there WAS ad oubt btw, considering it was almsot always swinging between 49-51 and 50-50 :P

    ciao :)

  206. I demand a recount! Check those chads!

  207. Shana lost? NOOOO~~~~~~~~~

    I second the recount. Unfortunately, I think there are ways of cheating that makes it impossible to catch.

    I also just realized that I voted for the losing side for EVERY SINGLE match! Am I really weird in my preferences? Oh well. I guess the gods of female anime character polls (AKA Jason & co) are out to get me or something.

    Now it’s the finals, and it’s between two characters that I don’t particularly care about, so I guess this will be my last post on the matter.

  208. meh

    whatever.

    in the end, the winner doesn’t have to win big.

    Just WIN.

    Now on to Belldandy vs Chidori.

    That one will be a toughie.
    (jluglue gets a coin ready to flip)

  209. Oh man, Shana lost… T_T

    Oh well, now on to the next poll, though i don’t think it would be as intense as this one…

    Shana LOST!!! Noooooo!!!! >__

  210. this is revenge time…. chidori’s got my vote…. I’ll put down Belldandy to HELL

  211. >> I demand a recount! Check those chads!

    I’m guessing that both sides cheated equally. o_O

    >> I also just realized that I voted for the losing side for EVERY SINGLE match!

    I predicted Lacus would win the tournament, so don’t feel bad. I misjudged how pro-loli the readers are.

  212. “I’m guessing that both sides cheated equally. o_O”

    Except you tried harder on catching Shana cheaters…. Just kidding.

    “I predicted Lacus would win the tournament, so don’t feel bad. I misjudged how pro-loli the readers are.”

    I haven’t had much luck in general lately. I hope I am saving all that unused karma for something important LOL.

    Wait…. I just said that the previous post was the last one, and 10 minutes later I posted again. Oh well. I am going to sleep now.

  213. *Commits sepukku

  214. Hah. Shana-chan’d wipe the floor with Belldandy any day! XP

  215. Belldandy…nuff said…you cannot beat a goddess, even if she loses in a simple poll!

  216. Noo! Poor Shana lost :(
    Now I know Chidori is gonna win :)

  217. SHANAAAAA ftw

  218. It over my friends…

    This time we lost, but sooner or later, time to payback will come.

  219. well i vote for BELLDANDY!!! no more explanation…she’s a perfect women!!!

  220. Hahahaha!! i vote for BELLDANDY too.. your right keiichiroy..belldandy is perfect..

  221. Belldandy

  222. Well, Shana gets my vote because shes the first anime show that rele touched me and the storyline of her shows are rele GREAT!! Belldandy…..well shes boring and i hope she gets the lowest votes! >:o Shana wins because her shows have more excitement and always leave a big cliff hanger which makes people like it more. Shana, u rule! My vote goes to U!! ^_^

  223. To all those that voted Shana.. You would rather have an insane loli muppet than the.. Goddess.
    Facepalm.jpeg

  224. I’ll vote for Belldandy perfect female anime ever

  225. I’ll vote for Belldandy perfect female anime ever

    wait how can i vote???

  226. Belldandy is the best.

Leave a Reply