melancholy of haruhi suzumiya 14 discussion

“Our movements. Our elevations. Our relaxtions. Our Haruhi. To warm us up. To calm us down. Off we go.”

image

What a ride. Like a roller coaster, I’m a bit whoozy after it all.

Greatest sequence in this series has to be Kyon describing Haruhi’s changing hairstyles. So incredibly funny and what signaled to me that SHnY wasn’t going to be your run of the mill anime. That’d make a good post/poll wouldn’t it? Favorite Haruhi scene/moment. – zero

There’s no way I can make a poll like that and get it under 50 choices. A few of my favorites…

Haruhi’s epic “healthy girl” rant… Cowering Mikuru… “the victim would be Mikuru!”… “you look great in a ponytail”… Loli-in-a-bag… God Knows… any Mikuru costume-raping… “men are potatoes”… Yuki vs Ryoko… Haruhi jumping on computer club prez’s bed… “THE SECOND RAIDO!”… turn-around and say “好き”… any LOL FANG-TAN laughter… Haruhi’s changing hairdo… “classified information”… Kyon’s secret Mikuru folder… Yuki preventing Haruhi from entering the room… All-Woman Mikuru… Mikuru and Kyon’s “day-to”… “you’re face is too close”… “ruined for marriage”… Koi no Mikuru Densetsu… Haruhi and Kyon under the umbrella… Mikuru’s mole… Itsuki staring at Kyon’s mole… “I have a long list of complaints against Haruhi”… “Asahina-san lower body workout”… R&GAD… the drop kick… Haruhi forcing Mikuru to eat spoiled food… Yuki’s fortune telling… Nurse Mikuru… Hare Hare Yukai (and it’s Gundam version)… bunny girls… bunny girl with machine gun… “day-to ja nai no!”… Haruhi with cardigan and thigh-highs… Yuki’s use of an optical mouse… “Mikuru beam!”… Haruhi’s tsundere look after the baseball game… Haruhi transferring her “spirit” to Kyon… Mikuru staring at Mori… Mikuru taking pictures of sleeping Kyon… Yuki’s reading list… “otomodachi”… Kyoto Animation’s upcoming announcement of a new 52 episode run…

Let’s come up with a list of favorite quotes for Jason.

“That’s when I thought, ‘Ah, they really aren’t human.’”

“All these people lined up for some bad fried soba made from cheap stuff. We’re raking it in! I can’t stop laughing!”

“She doesn’t care as long as she can read, apparently. I suppose you could call her an oddball.”

“She’s planning on turning this room into an I-have-no-idea-what club.”

“You can’t rent Yuki without my permission!… She’s the SOS Brigade’s indispensable silent character! I saw her first!” – wp

There are a lot of awesome and memorable quotes from Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya. I’m thinking of compiling a quote index when I get some time… if you guys can spare some time and help me out, suggest quotes along with the episode from which it came from. Thanks. (My personal favorite is still Haruhi’s “healthy girl” rant. If I had to sum up the series with one paragraph, I’d just copy and paste that quote. Mikuru’s screams when costume raped would be in the top five.)

Personally, my favorite thing about this episode was Haruhi’s reaction to the giant monsters. “Look Kyon! Space monsters/Ancient Bioweapons are destroying the city! This. Is so. Frelling. AWESOME!” (paraphrased somewhat) – Googleshng

I still liked Haruhi’s “baka ja nai no!!!” after Kyon talks about ponytails. That, my friends, is pure, 100%, organic, all natural, no preservative tsundere.

If there was a Haruhi drinking game for every chara’s quirks, how many people would pass out by the third episode? And would all that alcohol impair your ability to have a Haruhigasm?- Kamal

Great idea! Haruhi Suzumiya Drinking Game, version 1…

“Zenzen” (1 drink)
Kyon touches his head (1)
“Uguu~~” from Mikuru (1)
Mikuru pouring tea (1)
LOL FANG-TAN laughter (1)
Seeing Mikuru’s bra (1)
Winking (1)
Yuki adjusting her glasses (1)
“Your face is too close” (2)
Costume raping (2)
Seeing anyone other than Mikuru’s bra (2)
Character other than Mikuru pouring tea (2)
Object (straw, pencil, Kyon, etc) touching Haruhi’s lips (3)
Haruhi locking the SOS Brigade’s door (3)
Optical mice leaving surface (5)

Speaking of episode 14, my favorite part was the music; we need it, one more Evangelion-type classic scene with a giant destroyed everything meanwhile our hero and heroine runoff without a care for the world behind. – Syaoran Li

You mean have Kyon and Haruhi run to school in the morning, only he plows into new exchange student Mikuru (who is chomping on some toast), sees her panties, and has Really Pissed Off Haruhi to deal with for the rest of the day?

image

Actually, I think CCC’s assigning of roles is really dead on. Kyon::Shinji (dragged along by the events), Haruhi::Asuka (tsudere), Yuki::Rei (clones of each other), All-Woman Mikuru::Misato (hawtness), Itsuki::Kaoru (gay friend), but I’d make Imouto::Pen-Pen and LOL FANG-TANG::Three Magi, just to get the computers to hysterically break out in laughter each time Misato’s “chance for success” calculation comes back as 0.001%. But that’s just me.

The vocal albums are out btw. I’m not too sure what to say about them. – Korockid

I liked Aya Hirano’s, but Yuki’s seiyuu singing… it caught me off guard. I can’t imagine Yuki singing. Doesn’t fit her. It’s like Steve Kerr rapping or David Hasselhoff pretending he’s younger than 40. I’d prefer an LOL FANG-TAN CD that’s just 74 minutes of her laughing… or maybe an Itsuki and Kyon duet album for the fangirls.

(I’m not sure if I like the Hoff video or the Kerr video more… one has KITT, the other has free throw shooting footage… tough, tough choice. Almost as difficult as Nurse Mikuru vs Combat Waitress Mikuru.)

i still don’t understand WHY Haruhi picked Kyon tho . .. – takahashi

He dialed a wrong number and got the SOS Brigade Hotline. Next thing he knew, he made a dumb (or really intelligent wish) and here we are.

i would have liked it better if haruhi didnt wear her stockings/necktie/cuffs on her bunny-girl costume as it was in the novel. – EcchiOtaku

I think the outfit is a lot hawter with all the accessories. If she didn’t have them, it’ll just be an ugly brown single piece swimsuit with stockings.

I can’t imagine how Kyon could just sit there playing Othello when beside him is a girl in bunny costume braiding a whimpering maid. Me and my friend couldn’t really decide that the line “Actually… ponytails turn me on,”was altered from the original for a comedic purpose (and a sneaky reference to FMP: Fumouffuu). – Xeifa

No, it wasn’t altered. I even gave it away in episode 13’s discussion post.

(Honestly, if a hawt girl in a bunny costume is braiding a whimpering meido next to me, I would *censored* *censored* *censored* and *censored*.)

Mikuru just makes me happy.

image

What company do you think will bring Haruhi to America? – Nemo_N

Glad someone asked this. When I left for vacation, I was planning to make a prank post, “Funimation announces Haruhi Suzumiya license at AX.” I decided against it and tossed up that wallpaper post, since joking about this would be bad karma… and Funimation may actually license it and put Naruto trailers on the DVD. I’m hoping for Geneon… just because they’re bound to include some sort of Mikuru-run bonus item with their boxsets. Also, it gives the show a 0.01% chance of getting shown on some cable channel (perfect for AU on G4). I’d love to see it aired on TV in the states.

(With the rumors of E7 and IGPX bombing, yes, contrived shows don’t do well here… then again, Paranoia Agent didn’t do well either so far off shows aren’t much better. Still, Betterman and Crest of the Stars did pretty good on Anime Unleased, one of the few survivors from the old TechTV. I can see Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya thriving there.)

There is an Anime most moe tournament going on in japan right now, i think its from july 5th all the way to october, which is the battle of all moe characters through out this summer. So far SOS dan members are dominating. – Onibaku

That’s right, only 200+ more days till the next March Madness tournament.

But besides the marvelous, wonderful, nay, SCRUMPTOUS male characters that are Kyon and Itsuki, I must naturally give it all up for Haruhi. For with her, all things are possible. Even if it means the end of the world. – Minako134

I was watching (against my will) Things I Like About You, and the token black guy on the show kept saying “lesbionic.” I have no idea what this word means. I’m really off-topic. Anyway, fangirls are scary.

i’m still confused about All Woman Mikuru’s clue back in episode 10. She gave the hint “Snow White.” I thought that would be brought up this episode, but it apparently has been changed to “Sleeping Beauty” by Yuki. Production error? I’m confused. – kei-clone

It’s correct. Two different people gave Kyon the same hint two ways. Both fairy tales involve a prince kissing a sleeping princess to wake her up.

(Though I still like Full Metal Panic‘s parody of Cinderrella when Sagara becomes Chidori’s fairy godmother armed with bazookas, grenades, and everything. They could do a similar thing with Haruhi as Mikuru’s fairy godmother and having Haruhi costume rape Mikuru into various outfits: pumpkin, princess, meido, etc. Mikuru meets Kyon at the ball, but before she has to leave at midnight, and she accidentially loses her meido bonnet behind, and then Kyon goes out looking for the fit for the bonnet. Only before he gets to Mikuru’s house, Godmother Haruhi pops up and forces Kyon to go film a movie with her. This could work…)

Now we just need more Adult Mikuru, and some Alternate Yuki, to get things rolling for whatever following seasons or OVAs may appear in the future. – Haesslich

Hoping for a Detective Conan-type of run for Haruhi… 450+ episodes, 10+ movies, etc. Nagaru Tanigawa needs to start cracking on more chapters. Anyone know his/her address so I can ship some caffine pills over there?

Hopefully Haruhi-sama will keep her pony tail and grow her hair for the second coming, err… season. Bah, back to work. – Crusader

Yet more support for season two and beyond. We need to start up some sort of online petition… are those things still popular anymore, or are they so 2001? (Yes, I signed the online petition protesting ADV’s use of overlays in Nadesico back then… just trying to establish some fanboy street cred.)

image

Have a scanslated dojin with this premise in mind:
http://kawaiiheavens.net/index.php?z=projects_hnk

Enjoy. – skribulous

Caution: H!

I once again demand a post showing the choronological order to watch the episodes. Very much ^_^ – Sieg

I recommend Strato’s webpage for this info. I also like Strato’s novel translation a bit more. Or you can wait for my upcoming post mortum on Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya.

After seeing her in the operner, I thought she’d play a slightly bigger role in the series than she did – do anyone know if she IS more than just a random student? – Ida

As Poke pointed out, I think she’s an alien as well. In league with Yuki to bring some excitement into Haruhi’s life, just like what Itsuki did with Remote Island Syndrome. I’m hoping that Mikuru flirting with Kyon is her way of inciting Haruhi…

I bet we will see more of her later, she IS in the op. – Poke

All you need to know about anime OPs is the original opening to ああっ女神さまっ OVA where they show like Mara and Senbei and other characters… and they never make it into the series. Or Mai Otome, which showed “Mai”… who didn’t show up until the show was beyond repair. The worst offender is probably Gundam Seed where they give out major plot points in the OP like ten episodes too early.

>>They’re officially the AC Slater/Jessie Spano of the anime world.

This is ridiculously true! I can see Haruhi bitching at Kyon about little things, but in the end sucumming to Kyon’s cynical nature. Not to mention Kyon constantly pushing his rational onto Haruhi. Although I don’t see Kyon blurting out, “Haruhi, why don’t you be a woman and cook,” unless he wants some to do the nasty with her a la Adam and Eve. – deftoned

I think if Kyon told Haruhi to shut up and cook, it would end the world ten times over. Still, if it eventually leads to Haruhi starring in a movie about strippers, I’m all for it. She even has the bunny girl waitress outfit ready.

Is there some sort of cultural significance to the synchronized brushing? They also did it in the Read or Die series and (I think) in Evangelion as well… I’m beginning to think this is a particular way to establish closeness between characters–it happens in Eva only after the team gets to know each other and it happens in ROD as sort of a way to establish the special bond between the paper sisters. Are they going for the same thing between Kyon and his duffel-dwelling companion? – Av4rice

I’d rather see synchronized brushing between Imouto and Mikuru, which could redefine “kawaii” as we know it. The kawaii meter would so totaled, I won’t even be able to return it back for a 30 day refund.

Why was there no naked LOL-FANG-TAN? – Komidol

>> Why was there no costume raping for LOL FANG-TAN?

Fixed.

Imouto almost steals the show… (BTW, her blurb on wikipedia is now longer than Yuki’s blurb… something ain’t right…)

image

So, Is it time to decide who is Mikuru?, The sister of Kyon?, The daughter of Kyon?, Another inconcebible thing? – Freddie®

Imouto-san has different eye color than Mikuru, so I doubt she grows up into Mikuru… but it’s possible she can be Haruhi and Kyon’s love child, as Komidol nicely illustrates. I just love how Imouto-san and Kyon don’t have real names… and I noticed that their house doesn’t have a nameplate out front. Also, Itsuki and LOL FANG-TAN don’t have full names either. Keeps some mystery in the show; it would be hilarious if it turned out that Kyon and Imouto’s family name was really é•·é–€.

As for Imouto-san, she borrowed the scissors for her killer loli guest appearance in Higurashi! I bet she was the one who knocked off Rika-chan at the temple in episode 13. – Fat Cat Lim

Best. Theory. Ever. I think it would be great if Detective Haruhi and Assistant Kyon travelled back to Hinamizawa and tried to solve the Oyashiro-sama curse. I can imagine Haruhi finding the Oyashiro torture room and ranting on, “What is this silly curse? I see a room filled with movie props. It’s probably a figment of their primitive imaginations. Trying to get me excited about some pranks. It’s probably like those crop circles. Kyon! Are you listening?” *silence* “So what costume should Mikuru try next?”

I had to watch the opening scene several times, because I was too transfixed on imouto-san hopping and tuggin on Kyon to pay attention to what Kyon was saying (I watched the scene 15 times now: I still don’t know what Kyon said in the opening scene). – Xeifa

I noticed that Imouto-san was spanking Kyon. I think anyone who enjoyed this sequence would enjoy Chokotto Sister.

Just how much does it cost to get a morning call from Kyon’s sister? – DF

Yep… these are my readers.

image

27 Responses to “melancholy of haruhi suzumiya 14 discussion”

  1. Is the “What is this? This sensation” an official picture of the novels or just one that someone made?

  2. It’s a doujin, which means fan-made, so someone else made it.

    Anyways great pictures =)

  3. What? Koizumi Itsuki? He’s got a surname.

    I still want to know how (un)official that character cross-evaluation chart was.

  4. . . .

    all of these pics should be in a larger size… especially that last one :3

    I fully support a 52 episode “second season”, especially if it involves lol-fang-tan or costume raping…

  5. OH SNAP, is Crazy Clover Club doing a Haruhi doujinshi?? I must find it!!

  6. >> Actually, I think CCC’s assigning of roles is really dead on. Kyon::Shinji (dragged along by the events)…

    Yeah I guess. But Shinji is a loser, and Kyon is not. :P

  7. (Had Kyon been Kaji it would’ve been even better)

    The Disappearence of Suzumiya Haruhi I think would be at the heart of the next Haruhi with more bits and pieces from Rampage. (Endless Eight… 15,498… fufufu…) I hope the next Haruhi when it does materialize would capture the well-versed Kyon even better. (not many people would mirror Surigao Strait, 1944 to the odds of winning a game)

    More in-depth Mikuru would be great too. (Nagato gets alot of attention in the novel and so does Koizumi). The story behind Tanabata hinted in “someday in the rain” still needs to be told to turn the audience’s head upside-down. There’s alot of depth to go with the rabbit hole…

  8. Now that somebody says that s/he doesnt understand WHY Haruhi choose Kyon… Well, apart from maybe being the only human being able to talk with her, maybe reading Bamboo Leaf Rhapsody will clear youy doubts.

  9. … Bill?

    Totally agree with you about the “healthy girl” rant in SHnY IV. It’s especially effective when you watch it right after SHnY III; since there was, what? a 5 episode gap between these two parts, it completely recaps that episode, too!

  10. I second the motion for larger pics, preferrably another Haruhi wallpaper blow out (I demand the second to last one). My work internet connection is going to be severed soon until the bloody connectivity contract gets done, bah! I just ordered 5 Haruhi CDs from Kinokuniya so when I get back I’ll at least have something to listen to while I twidle my thumbs waiting for the internet to come back to the new office. I hope my hard earned money is not being filtered for Kanon.

  11. Me and my MS Paint skills are always here for yah, Jason.

  12. Larger Pics Please! The sixth image (from top) to be precise!

    Man, I won’t be able to resist temptation and will start reading the novels’ translations. This will spoil the rest of the anime, but I need my Haruhi fix. BTW…

    >>>I also like Strato’s novel translation a bit more.

    I haven’t read Strato’s translations but, what is the difference? I ask this because I don’t speak japanese and I would like to know if it makes a huge difference which translation I read.

    Yo Jason! Could you blog about Today in Class 5-2? I would like to know what do you think of it!

  13. jason, gogo blog zero no tsukaima 2 as soon as you watch it~

  14. Just as a small detail: Did anyone else notice that the taxi driver who drivers Kyon and Itsuki to the Closed Space (or however it’s called) is the buttler in the Island episode?

  15. They seemed relatively similair in character design, though there’s really no honest proof it was the same guy.

    I would like to know where you find all these wonderful pictures though Jason…especially the first one.

    No not for moron Mikuru, Haruhi! Look at her hot ass in the air like that…yes…

  16. I so love Mr. Plamo (Mr. Creator of Gundam edition anime scenes). Nearly brings tears to my eyes.

    Must see for those who haven’t:
    God Knows Concert http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mS2q7t8Kk7I

    and…

    Mikuru introduction scene in Ep. 2
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Js-d6OxiZ9I

    I long to see the whole series done in this fashion. I long with my whole body, especially… anyway.

  17. Another reason why I wouldn’t want to see the 2nd season produce by any company but kyoto ani:

    http://www.milchclan.com/haruh...../index.php

    btw, does anyone notice that it’s always the same cars that they r showing in the series ? yellow beetles , ,white primus .. . even in the remote island ep

    ps. it’s amazing to see how much time ppl devote to haruhi.

    http://haruhiclass.jf.land.to/.....=060612_01

  18. >>More in-depth Mikuru would be great too. (Nagato gets alot of attention in the novel and so does Koizumi). The story behind Tanabata hinted in “someday in the rain” still needs to be told to turn the audience’s head upside-down. There’s alot of depth to go with the rabbit hole…

    Mikuru actually does get more story in volume 7, we also learn some background about Tsuruya in that volume too, which is pretty suprising. She may have a much bigger role than just a side character.

  19. I went to Stratos’ page, and holy crap. The anime is almost completely by the book. Down to the clothing descriptions.

  20. >>> That’s right, only 200+ more days till the next March Madness tournament.

    So, that means we can have field of 64, with 3 to 4 day window of voting for each match, right? Love to see your seed #1 to #64, as well as the 4 region group’s name.

  21. Second season will probably add a bit more to the hints in season one.

    Example- In episode 9 (Someday in the rain) Near the window in the club room, you can see a bamboo stalk with wishes from everyone stringed to it. I’m guessing they’ll have a bamboo leaf rhapsody episode. I mean, that the chapter where Kyon goes back in time to see mini Haruhi x3

    Guess I’m back to re-watching the episodes, just to find little hints that maybe weren’t found. (I just spotted the bamboo stalk while re-watching Ep. 9)

  22. I’m suspecting another season since, business-wise, it would be a smart idea. But just because they include all those little details isn’t really a sign of anything. Kyoto Animation is just really damn good. In the episode where Yuki defends Kyon from Asakura, notice how Yuki has her name written on the back of her sneakers. That was one sentence in the novel.

  23. After more reading an anaylysis, these are my findings concerning 2nd season.

    1. Since this series has generated much publicity and revenue through INTERNATIONAL book and CD sales, it makes sense, business wise, to make a 2nd season of 10+ episode.

    2. The juiciest chapters of the novel has mostly been used up, so there is inevitable decline of quality of source material, which suggests that, unless they dramatically increase animation and music quality or introduce some great original stories, many people will take the 2nd season and some what a let down. Still, the remaining materials are good enough to leave most other anime series in dust; it just is that the expectations will be very high, but lack of better plot foundation means 2nd season cannot reach the level of 1st season.

    3. It is likely that they will either wait until release of 9th novel, or a year or two to start making 2nd season. KyoAni will need even more resources to do the 2nd season and it will take some time to gather those resources, and perhaps even more time to make and polish the 2nd season. The 9th novel scenario will be the one leading to the least time before the 2nd season, as book publishers will gladly pump in money in order to synchronize the broadcast of episodes of 2nd season with start of book sale of the 9th novel. In that scenario, we can expect some materials from 9th novel to be included in the episodes.

    4. Popularity of Tsuruya and Kyon’s sister will mean that they will get more screen time than suggested by the novel.

    5. Shamisen, the cat, will probably get to say more than what is written in the book, in order for them to reduce voice actor payment per line spoken. If I remember, they have the legendary veteran Kenichi Ogata doing Shamisen.

    Finally, is it safe to assume that Mikuru will get one of the #1 seed in coming tournament?

  24. Random YouTube Video

    ..) Reason 4282 why Taniguchi will never forgive Kyon.
    ~~~~ ~~~~

    Cheers. :P

  25. You know, it occured to me that it would be amusing if they made a trailer for international release spliced of the various scenes in SHaruhi, such as the baseball game, the school festival concert, the LAN battle, etc… and at the end of it all, one line.

    “Guess the genre.”

    If anything, it would screw around with the minds of non-viewers, like how Ep00 screwed most of ours’.

  26. Strato’s translation is unbelievably better. Translation via Wiki is one of the worst ideas ever (I translate myself and have seen the results of translation by committee). The Wiki version generally over-translates (lots of unnecessary bits that don’t make sense in English) and has a tin ear for slang/common sayings.

  27. I’m just afraid of the Haruhi Merchendise rush…

    Konami Presents

    The Dating Sim of Haruhi Suzumiya

    Who will Kyon end up with in the SOS club?
    Will it be the shy and esoteric beauty, Yuki?
    Will it be the chipper and busty loli, everyone’s favorite time travelling meido, Mikuru?
    Will it be the exuberent and megolomaniac leader and god, Haruhi?
    OR
    Will Kyon suddenly get a desire to go to the unconventional side, and explore “closed space” with th handsome and intelligent psychic, Itsuki?
    The choice is yours! includes 12 different endings and an extra side mode with LOL-FANG-TAN!

    Coming in 2007

    Also be on the lookout for the spinoff series SOS Brigade: Interdimensional Field Trip Chronicles!
    What happens with the gang decides to jump into different worlds? Hilarity!

    When the Haruhi Cries

    Haruhi: “4 killer lolis and an evil God? I’m gonna likethe meido on this one!”
    Rika: “What are you doing, deshu deshu?”
    Haruhi: “Just meidoing you up, Rika!”
    K1: “I like her.”
    Kyon: “Go ahead, keep her. Besides, it’s not like we’ve stumbled onto the true identity of Oyashiro sama yet.”
    Mikuru: …Uso!

    SOS Host Club

    Tamaki: “We’ve decided to keep Itsuki as our new member.”
    Itsuki: “I’m the psychic type ^ – ^ ”
    Twins: “We like Itsuki-chan!”
    Kyon: “Go ahead keep him…”
    Haruhi: “It’s on now bitch!”
    Haruhi: “Only one Haruhi can exist in this dimension!”
    Renge: “YESSSSS! DANCE PUPPETS, DANCE!”

    COMING SOON!!!

Leave a Reply